Lazy Slow Cooker Mashed Potatoes: dairy and dairy free!
Jump to Recipe
Mashed Potatoes - they are classic. From weeknight dinner tables to holiday buffets and down-home diners to elegant wedding receptions, the mashed potato is never out of place.
It’s neutral coloring goes with every outfit. I know that to be fact, because I have washed droppings of it off every color and type of clothing!
The most decadent ”mash-po” recipes feature cream, cheese and cream cheese making them rich in flavor and texture, but heavy in calories. The lighter versions contain stock and sometimes skim milk and while not as creamy, are still delicious.
These Lazy Slow Cooker recipes fall somewhere in the middle. Healthy enough to serve on a regular basis, yet still creamy and tasty enough to make holiday appearances.
The challenge was to develop a super easy dairy-free recipe that lives up to the dairy version in every way. So, we took out the dueling slow cookers, ran some trials, and conducted side-by-side comparisons.
Want to save this recipe for later?
I'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
When the final dairy-free version was served next to its dairy cousin, the team could not tell them apart. Lazy Slow Cooker Mashed Potato success!
If you love this recipe, please let me know in the comment section below!
Lazy Slow Cooker Mashed Potato Hacks
- There is tons of information online about what types of potatoes mash best. My favorite for mashing is Yukon Gold or Butter potatoes
- The laziest way to make these recipes is to buy potatoes that are pre-cleaned and peeled.
- Contrary to my usual lazy self, I did not follow step 2! BUT....I did discover a peeling/cutting hack! I used my apple peeler/corer. It quickly and easily took the skin right off and spiralized the potatoes. I was able to put them right into the slow cooker without any further cutting. Since it is meant for apples, the device pulls out a “core”. I just cut off the ends and tossed those into the slow cooker too.
- If you don’t have an apple corer/peeler, I did discover that there is an electric potato peeler on the market. I don’t know anything about it other than it looks really cool. If anyone has tried it, please let me know if you like it and if you think it is worth investing in.
- These recipes call for mashing the potatoes by hand. Nothing fancy, not much in the way of extra dishes to wash and the end result is creamy and delicious.
- Both the dairy and dairy-free versions of this recipe involve introducing milk towards the end of the cooking time. Regardless of whether you are using dairy milk or an alternative, it is important to slightly warm the milk and only stir in a small amount at a time.
- For the non-dairy version of these potatoes, I used original flavored Nutpods as my "milk".
- I am a big fan of slow cooker liners because I am lazy and like the easier clean-up. They are always optional, of course.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small amount from qualifying purchases and affiliate links at no additional cost to you.
📖 Recipe
Lazy Slow Cooker Mashed Potatoes (dairy and dairy-free option)
Equipment
- 3.5 or larger slow cooker
- potato masher
- apple peeler/corer (optional)
- knife
- cutting board
- Optional: slow cooker liner for easier clean up
Ingredients
- 5 lbs butter potatoes, peeled and chopped its not pretty, but a traditional apple peeler/corer can really helpful with this step. See Lazy Hacks above for link.
- 1 cup turkey broth
- ½ cup butter product I used regular, salted butter for the dairy version and Earth's Balance for the non.
- 1 cup milk of choice for the dairy version, I used whole milk. For the non-dairy, I used Nutpods original flavor. See Lazy Hacks for link.
- 2 teaspoon freshly ground garlic salt
Instructions
- Peel and cut 5 lbs butter potatoes, peeled and chopped(this where I used my apple corer/peeler)
- Place into slow cooker and cover with 1 cup turkey broth
- Place lid on slow cooker and cook on high 4-6 hours or until potatoes are easily mashed by hand.
- When potatoes are soft, use hand potato masher to fully mash potatoes. I have read of potatoes that become gummy from over mashing. I have not experience this myself and I am thinking that it is because I mash them by hand and do not use an immersion blender or mixer.
- Add ½ cup butter product into hot mashed potatoes and allow to melt then stir in.
- Slightly warm 1 cup milk of choice (I used the microwave for this) and add in a few tablespoons at a time until desired consistency is reached. I did not wind up using the full cup for either the dairy or non-dairy recipe. Adding too much liquid will make your potatoes soupy.
- Stir in 2 teaspoon freshly ground garlic salt (or more to taste)
- Once fully mixed, turn slow cooker to warm and keep potatoes warm until it is time to serve them.
- Enjoy!!
Notes
Nutrition
Check out my latest on Instagram
Marcia says
The garlic salt is not mentioned in the instructions. Do you put it in with the broth and potatoes or later with the butter and milk?
The Lazy Slow Cooker says
Thank you for pointing that out to me - I am not sure where that step went, but it has been added back in. I generally stir in the garlic salt last so I can taste it as I go.